“Trust fund solvency is not
a meaningful measure of the government’s ability to meet its future
obligations.”
Congressional Budget
Office
“There are no economic
assets in the Social Security trust fund.”
Office of Management and
Budget
“In the Federal
budget, the term 'trust fund' means only that the law requires a particular
fund be accounted for separately, used only for a specified purpose, and
designated as a trust fund. A change in law may change the future receipts and
the terms under which the fund’s resources are spent. In the private sector,
trust fund refers to funds of one party held and managed by a second party (the
trustee) in a fiduciary capacity.”
Trust funds
are simply accounts labeled that way in law. The funds are established to record collections that are earmarked in
legislation for the specific purposes for which the funds were established.
Federal government trust funds differ
from private trust funds in significant ways:
- Claims by private trust funds
against future output are limited by the value of the funds' assets. By
contrast, federal trust funds function as accounting mechanisms that
record tax receipts, user fees, and other credits and associated
expenditures. When receipts exceed expenditures, the government's books
show trust fund balances. According to the Office of Management and
Budget, "These balances are available to finance future benefit
payments and other trust fund expenditures but only in a bookkeeping sense.
These funds are not set up to be
pension funds, like the funds of private pension plans. They do not
consist of real economic assets that can be drawn down in the future to
fund benefits. Instead, they are claims on the Treasury that, when
redeemed, will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing from the
public, or reducing benefits or other expenditures. The existence of large
trust fund balances, therefore, does not, by itself, have any impact on
the Government's ability to pay benefits."1
- The beneficiary of a private
trust fund usually owns the fund's income and often owns its assets. The
trustee of a private trust fund has a fiduciary responsibility to manage
the fund on behalf of its beneficiaries and cannot make unilateral changes
to the provisions governing the trust. In contrast, federal trust funds
are owned by the federal government.2 They are created in
legislation. Lawmakers can change the amount of receipts and payments
flowing into and out of federal trust funds, add to or subtract from trust
fund balances, alter the purposes of the funds, and even eliminate them
altogether.
- Private trust funds are more
likely to represent saving--that is, forgoing current consumption for
future uses--than are federal trust funds. In that manner, the assets of
private trust funds add to net national savings and thus promote growth,
producing a return for the beneficiary and for the economy.
Congressional Budget Office